SECOND review of the Man Who Fell to Earth
Apr. 8th, 2006 05:17 pm"Okay, now that I have more distance between me and this movie, I can take a somewhat more level look at it. My first review I wrote while still in the anguish this movie induced in me. First off: with what this movie strives for, it would've earned either 1 star or 5 stars from me, nothing in between. This isn't a mediocre, average work. It isn't even an average bad work. It has moments of both sheer, stark brillance and awful, chaotic muddliness.
This is the first movie off Netflix that has ever moved me to write a review. It's not very forgettable. And I wasn't exaggerating about the movie hurting me, it actually caused a headache and dizziness in me. The only movie that's ever caused physiological reactions like that in me. And I still have images from it stuck in my head.
The low budget hurts it (the alien scenes're a little more tacky than they could be, especially the ones with the 'train'). The characters're kinda shallow, really (the female love interest, for example, whose only thought seems to be pursuit of the main character's affections). And the excessive scene transitions don't help (though they did stimulate very effectively in me the main character's cultureshock-induced illness).
But rating this solely on the sheer power of its imagery, it would be a 5. The 1 is for execution." - from my second Netflix review of The Man Who Fell to Earth. Yes, it moved me so much I wrote a second review.
This is the first movie off Netflix that has ever moved me to write a review. It's not very forgettable. And I wasn't exaggerating about the movie hurting me, it actually caused a headache and dizziness in me. The only movie that's ever caused physiological reactions like that in me. And I still have images from it stuck in my head.
The low budget hurts it (the alien scenes're a little more tacky than they could be, especially the ones with the 'train'). The characters're kinda shallow, really (the female love interest, for example, whose only thought seems to be pursuit of the main character's affections). And the excessive scene transitions don't help (though they did stimulate very effectively in me the main character's cultureshock-induced illness).
But rating this solely on the sheer power of its imagery, it would be a 5. The 1 is for execution." - from my second Netflix review of The Man Who Fell to Earth. Yes, it moved me so much I wrote a second review.